Joel Stein's recent article
My Own Private India has caused a huge uproar amongst my fellow Indians and also most of the NRI's who have been a part of Uncle Sam's country for quite a few decades. The article already did get its deserved share of rantings from all corners of the world. I am no different from all those who have been critical of the article but at the same time this article did raise a few questions in my wacky brain.
Born and brought up in a country where you have scores of religions, quite a few dozens of castes and sub-castes and infinitely many more languages, life in the US of A was totally a different league for me. I am pretty sure it must have been for most of the first timers here. I was so much fascinated by this country's warmth and broad mindedness though I did often miss the extra warmth of my Mother India. More importantly this country by far taught all the fellow country men to be united (ohh!! Yeah Indians too. No way I am deliberately taking a dig at my fellow country folks).
Let us for sometime be honest guys. How many times do we fight amongst ourselves back home? Pretty sure many of you must be well aware of the recent Telangana issue that has been rocking the state of Andhra Pradesh. Also not to forget Y. S. Jagan, son of the deceased Chief Minister YSR who has been keeping the current Government and the Chief Minister Mr. Rosaiah on their toes and not to forget the terrible nightmares that the Government is getting because of Jagan's Odarpu Yathra.
We fight amongst ourselves based on castes and also sub-castes. Some of these have even influenced the present day youth so much that they make friendship only based on the caste and totally alienate people from the other castes. Yes, this is quite true and can be very much visible to the naked eyes if you look at a few engineering colleges and medical colleges in Vijayawada and Vizag. Not to forget that the Telugu people are called "gultis" by the Tamil folks and the Tamil folks called "arravam" by the Telugu folks. Are we being ignorant or doesn't anyone know how the North Indians and South Indian wait for an opportunity to pick up on each other? I was one of those guys who was taunted as "idly-sambhar" quite a few times because I was from the southern part of India. All these finally stopped when I retorted back making fun of their region and language too which obviously was quite bad on my part. Yes!! For the fact I am being a hypocrite but all that was not in control. Are we no less racists when compared to Stein or the Aussies or the Brits?
Ok!! Enough beating around the bush. All this was just meant to be an eye-opener but honestly I am not in support of Stein's stale humorous article. Eye-opener?? Yes. The only time I see Indians uniting amongst them is when a third party comments on Indians as whole and not just one region. When we ourselves pick on at every instance of our lives, why get angry when someone else has called us "dot-heads"? Why can't we all be united at all times and not only at instances when a third person instigates us? Is that difficult or is it quite a herculean task?
It is going to be a herculean task until we change our attitudes and way of thinking. We need to believe that there is no religion above humanity and the feeling of oneness. No person or no country is perfect. So why rant about each other? Why make a fuss out of nothing? Doesn't every individual want some peace in his life?
Responses from
Deepa Iyer and
Kal Penn on Stein's article which might cool you guys down a bit but I don't think you would want to read
Sagarika Ghose's article to raise your tempers again. Honestly speaking, I totally concur with Sagarika's views as she was being utmost practical and to the core.
PS: You must visit Edison in NJ to see how Indianized it is. No wonder Stein was pissed off.